The Tale of Three Gift Sites - Comparing the Successes of Three Sites in the Same Niche
One of the biggest challenges our team faced when we started reeling in clients is the competition that clients faced with one another. While some people have this notion that working on similar sites is easy since we already know what to do, we looked at it from a different point of view. We viewed this as more of a puzzle that needed solving since we will be pitting different sites against one another AND we were the ones tasked with making each site earn more via our work.
Now, I’m sure some of you would wonder why we would take on such a monumental task. The answer is simple. We were up for the challenge (plus who are we to turn down perfectly viable clients?). So, we set about to get the work done for all of these same niche sites and to earn them the kind of income that they want to get from online ads.
We didn’t get all three sites at the same time, mind you. The first one, we got in the second quarter of the previous year. The second one came in three months after and the last one came in during the last quarter of the same year. This gave us the opportunity to get one site’s ads running and raking in the traffic as well as revenues before we needed to focus on the next one.
Suffice it to say that we were able to meet the revenue and traffic targets of all three and we will share with you some insights on how we achieved this, even though these three are in the same niche and feature almost the same products on their sites.
Client: Gift Sites
Industry: Gift, Specialty, and Niche
Campaign Type: Site Optimization, Google Ads, and Facebook Ads
Project Background
This study shows you that three ecommerce sites selling the same products and targeting almost the same market can get the kind of sales that they want with our help. As with most of the sites that come to us for help, these three needed some help in the optimization department. They also needed some help in bringing in targeted traffic, particularly since times were tough due to the pandemic.
Not all sites came to us in the same condition. One had adwork done in the past while another had some SEO done to it as well. The third one we got without any work done to it but it had been around for years. These differences we had to take into consideration so we could come up with the right strategy for each one. With the aim being the same for all three and all three being in direct competition with each other, we had our work cut out for us
Project Objective
The objectives we had for all three sites were generally the same – bring in targeted traffic and increase revenues. Some people might ask why we chose to work with the other two sites after we accepted the first one, and the answer is rather simple. There is enough room for these sites to earn. We knew that there are thousands of people out there who will want to buy their products, even though these were similar. The choice is up to the customers and all we had to do was give them that choice.
Project Challenges
The challenges we faced with this particular project did not happen all at the same time and weren’t all the same either. We worked on each site in waves, with the first one happening early last year, the second one three months after that, and the last one near the end of the year. This meant that we were able to get the ball rolling on the first one before we had to tackle the second one, and so on.
The main challenge for the first account we handled was the botched ad creation and the lack of optimization on the site. Since the site already used ads in the past, we had to find a way to move past that and to create better ads that worked better for the client. We also had to optimize the site to help make it more appealing to search engines and their bots.
The challenges that came with the second site included pages that were optimized the wrong way and someone who tried to launch ads for them as well. Add to this the challenge of a tighter budget than the first site we handled, which somewhat limited our strategies for them.
The last site came with a unique challenge that can be easily seen as a combination of the challenges we faced with the first and second site. This last gift site never had any pages optimized, like the first site, but it has been around for years. It also had a rather limited budget when compared with the first site, but the budget was higher than what we were given for the second site.
Now that you’ve seen what we had to work with, let’s check out the solutions we used for each site.
The Solutions
As always, we tackled these obstacles with a multi-pronged solution. While our first step is usually the same across the board, which is an audit of each site, we knew that a one-size-fits-all approach won’t work. Each site needed a customized solution for us to achieve the goals that we set for each one. Here are some of the things we did for each one.
First Site
For the first site, after the audit, we planned the usual optimization and the eradication of the old ads that they used for it. We then did the keyword research required for the niche as well as for the products that they sold. We then formulated various campaigns surrounding these keywords and got the input of the site owners on which products they wanted us to feature more.
We began planning where we would position the ads and at what times these should show. We set budgets for each campaign and brainstormed ad copy that we felt would work well with the pages on the site. We also contemplated which smart bidding strategies would work well for specific keywords and ads, based on careful study of the ads that we first put out.
Constant monitoring of these ads and split testing was crucial to the success of our work, so during the first three months, we kept a close watch on the movement of our ads and tweaked them as we went along.
Second Site
The second site came in three months after we began work on the first one. Seeing the beginnings of success on the first one, we were confident that we could help the second site achieve the same kind of trajectory. We didn’t know that the second site would prove to be more of a challenge.
After the audit, we saw that some pages were optimized but in a haphazard manner that made the pages look spammy. This had to be corrected. This site also had ads launched by someone who didn’t know what they were doing and thereby caused problems with the use of the wrong keywords, careless bids, and even ad copy that didn’t resonate with the brand. All of these had to be fixed before we could do any of our work for the site.
Third Site
The third site was a little less of a challenge than the second site, but since we already had two of the same kind of site on our hands, we almost didn’t take this one on. As with the first site, this didn’t have optimized pages. It also didn’t have any adwork done for it even though it had been around for years. We also saw that the site had a tight budget, but not as tight as the budget we had for the second site.
One other challenge that we had with this particular client was the fact that they wanted to get on the holiday bandwagon. Meaning, they wanted to get as much revenue as they can for the coming holidays since Thanksgiving and Christmas was fast approaching. This put some pressure on the team to get things done faster.
Similar Solutions for Similar Sites with Different Budgets
While the budget does play a substantial part in determining what we can do for a site, there are some things that we can do for all our customers, regardless of how high or how low their budget is. For starters, auditing and optimizing the site is a given since we do want to succeed in what we do.
Just to be clear though, our optimization consists only of the basics, which includes the use of the right keywords, keyword saturation, title and meta tags, alt tags, and so on. Optimization for the sake of ranking purposes, which includes outreach and other external factors, we don’t provide unless it’s requested and it comes with additional fees (it is additional work and will need a dedicated content creator plus outreach specialist to get done).
Aside from a basic audit and optimization, keyword research and ad creation as well as split testing of ads and daily monitoring are all done on all accounts. Tweaking of ads to ensure that we use the best performing keywords for all our ads and using the best ad copy according to our split testing is also done for all. We also ensure that these ads are made to appear where they are relevant, which in this case included Shopping, Search, Display, and Video.
For all ads, we also used smart bidding strategies to maximize on our budgets for each. This became extremely useful for those accounts that had rather limited budgets. We also excluded irrelevant queries, changed up keywords according to trends, and even launched new ads according to the holiday or season.
The Outcome
The result of our hard work is a marked increase in the traffic and sales of each site. This is despite the fact that all three sites shared the same niche and even had almost the same kinds of products on their pages. Of course, the level of success for each site isn’t the same and this is due to the amount of money we had to work with for each one.
As expected, the site that had the bigger budget for ads gained the most traction out of all three, raking in a staggering 5,000% increase in traffic in a matter of 6 months. This is because we are able to show their ads more than the others. When the adspend of the other two accounts run out, the first one continues since it had more room for such a thing to happen.
This doesn’t mean however that the other two lost out on the competition. They still got their fair share of the market and got more traffic as well as sales, as opposed to when they did not have any work done for them. Imagine getting upwards of a thousand unique visitors to your site in less than three months and a huge fraction of that traffic actually converting.
What Does This Prove?
This essentially proves that even though different sites in the same niche compete against one another, they can still claim success and earn enough from ads and marketing, as long as this is done the right way. And yes, budget does play a huge part in how much you earn from your ventures.
If you want to find out more about what we can do to help your website become a success, and to help it earn more, just contact us. We will be happy to answer any questions you have about our services and how we can help you get the results you want. Get in touch with us so we can schedule a consultation with you.
Note: Our case studies don’t come with the usual screenshots of our analytics and ad backend pages due to existing NDAs with the clients being mentioned in them.